I never really wanted to write about politics.
In all transparency, I still don’t.
For more than 15 years, I’ve written about relationships, family, and the complicated things that make us human. I’ve loved those topics. They’re personal, familiar, and, frankly, a lot more comfortable for me.
But here I am.
Over the years, I’ve built a readership that now reaches people in more than 20 countries, with thousands of readers visiting my site and following my writing.
I’d hate to lose readers after building back up my blog after many years because I’ve stepped into political territory.
But some things are bigger than readership.
I cannot fathom what has happened to our country since 9/11. Recently, I watched a documentary about the unity and togetherness that swept across America after the attacks. Nearly 3,000 people were murdered. Families were shattered. First responders ran toward danger. Strangers helped strangers. For a brief moment, the things that divided us seemed insignificant compared with what we shared at that moment.
We were Americans first.
Right?
And now, 25 years later, I hear people speak about that day with a revision of history so profound that the victims themselves seem to disappear from the story.
I hear arguments that somehow shift blame away from the terrorists who planned and carried out the attacks and toward the country that was attacked.
It feels like a different reality.
Years ago, I watched Freaky Friday with my young children. The premise was simple: A mother and daughter somehow switch bodies and suddenly experience life through each other’s eyes.
That is the closest comparison I have for what I’m feeling now.
It feels as if I woke up in a country I recognize physically, but barely recognize culturally.
And the horrific attacks no longer come in the form of airplanes.
On September 11, 2001, 19 al-Qaeda terrorists hijacked four commercial airplanes and carried out an attack that changed America forever.
Today, the battlefield is totally different. Now, information is the weapon.
Social media is the delivery system. And algorithms definitely amplify anger along with those “super vocal Influencers” and “commentators” who can now reach millions of people without the accountability that once came with traditional institutions. Half-truths, conspiracy theories, historical distortions, and outright falsehoods can travel around the world before facts have even put their shoes on.
The planes were once the vehicle. Now, information is.
And that should frighten all of us.
For those too young to remember, there is an expression: “Don’t drink the Kool-Aid.” It came from the tragedy at Jonestown in 1978, when hundreds of people died after being compelled to consume a poisoned drink at the direction of their cult leader, Jim Jones. The drink was actually Flavor Aid, but the phrase became shorthand for blindly accepting dangerous beliefs because someone you trust told you they were true. People throughout the years used to laugh and say out loud, how could anyone fall for it?
Well … it’s happening again.
This is the lesson that matters, and I will explain.
Blind allegiance is dangerous, regardless of who is asking for it.
Many outspoken influencers -who I shall not name because they don’t deserve it -and others across the political spectrum can present themselves as truth-tellers, outsiders, or fearless questioners of the establishment.
Questioning authority is healthy along with skepticism. Independent thinking is also essential.
But skepticism cannot mean believing everything that confirms what you already are desperately wanting to believe already.
That isn’t independent thinking. That is another form of indoctrination. Similar to Jim Jones.
We have seen versions of this throughout history.
The technology and personalities change. The delivery system changes, too. But the human vulnerability remains the same: People who are angry, frightened, isolated, or searching for certainty can become susceptible to anyone who promises simple answers to very complicated problems.
COVID exposed some of those vulnerabilities. It also accelerated our dependence on screens, social media, and information ecosystems that often reward anger rather than thought.
I believe in helping people who genuinely need help. I believe in compassion. I believe in opportunity.
But I also believe that a healthy society requires responsibility, work, contribution, and a moral compass.
America was never perfect. It never will be.
But our answer to imperfection cannot be to despise the country itself.
We can criticize America without hating America.
We can acknowledge its failures without erasing its achievements.
We can question our government without questioning the value of our country.
And we can disagree with one another without turning our fellow Americans into enemies.
That, to me, is the line we are dangerously close to crossing.
Before we are Democrats or Republicans, conservatives or liberals, before we are followers of this commentator or that influencer, we are Americans.
And if we lose sight of that, the greatest threat to this country may not be coming from somewhere else.
It may be coming from the stories we tell ourselves about who we are.
We are still Americans. The question is whether we will remember that before we lose what made us one.
And to all who celebrate the Jewish New Year:
Shanah tovah!
That’s my Reveal for the week.
Love,
Karin
If this blog resonated with you, you can receive pieces like this weekly in your inbox. Complete the pop-up form and subscribe today!